Member Participation Critical for 5-Year Review Process


The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has released the list of existing CPT® codes that are perceived as potentially misvalued, as part of the third 5-year review of the Medicare Fee Schedule (MFS). There are 39 radiology codes on this list, including interventional, computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance (MR), ultrasound, radiation oncology, plain film, dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA), and nuclear medicine codes. The survey process will begin in late May and continue through the summer.

In order for the ACR to make recommendations to the Relative Value Update Committee (RUC) on physician work, it will need to obtain a large number of surveys for these codes. It is crucial that ACR members actively participate in the survey process since over 90% of RUC recommendations for physician work RVUs have been accepted by CMS for its fee schedule, which then may be used by other payers as well.

If you and other radiologists or radiation oncologists in your practice would like to help complete surveys, please call the Economics and Health Policy Department at (800) 227-5463, ext 4584, or send an e-mail to economics@acr.org with your name and the type of survey(s) you would like to receive (ie, MR, CT, nuclear medicine, plain film, DXA, interventional, or ultrasound).

Radiology Codes Included in the 5-Year Review

The table below lists radiology codes in the 5-year review, allowed services, the specialty society that submitted the code, and the physician work value as published in the 2005 MFS.

Background

With the implementation of Medicare's resource-based relative value scale physician fee schedule in January 1992, a review of the relative value units associated with CPT® codes has been required by Congress no less than every 5 years. This review serves as a mechanism for CMS to identify misvalued codes and update them accordingly. Currently the review focuses only on the physician work component of specific procedures paid under the MFS. However, future reviews will include the practice expense (technical) component when the resource-based values are established in the MFS.

The list of codes compiled for the current 5-year review is based on comments CMS requested from the medical community and carrier medical directors to identify and nominate misvalued procedures, as well as CMS' own review. The list contains high-volume codes across specialties, codes that have not previously been reviewed by the RUC, and codes that were valued as being performed in the inpatient setting, but are now predominantly performed on an outpatient basis.

The data collected by the ACR will be presented to the RUC early in the fall. The values accepted by the RUC will be submitted to CMS for review by the end of this year. The final revised work values are expected to be released in November 2006 for a January 1, 2007, implementation. <

It is important to note that although CMS is soliciting public comments and involving the RUC and specialty organizations, CMS will ultimately decide whether the physician work value for the identified misvalued code will be increased or decreased.

If you have any questions regarding the 5-year review process, please contact the ACR Economics and Health Policy Department at (800) 227-5463, ext 4584, or send an e-mail to economics@acr.org.

Code Description Allowed Services
Code Submitted By
2005 Physician Work Values

22520 Percut vertebroplasty thor 12,395
CMS
8.9
43750 Place gastrostomy tube 32,798
CMS
4.48
47510 Insert catheter, bile duct 3,126
ACS
7.82
47511 Insert bile duct drain 5,325
ACS
10.48
47525 Change bile duct catheter 10,086
ACS
5.54
47530 Revise/reinsert bile tube 515
ACS
5.84
55700 Biopsy of prostate 241,521
CMS
1.57
62270 Spinal fluid tap, diagnostic 76,927
AAP
1.13
71010 Chest x-ray 18,344,071
CMS
0.18
71020 Chest x-ray 16,694,627
CMS
0.22
71260 CT thorax w/dye 1,843,380
CMS
1.24
72192 CT pelvis w/o dye 1,052,775
CMS
1.09
72193 CT pelvis w/dye 2,123,943
CMS
1.16
73100 X-ray exam of wrist 461,737
CMS
0.16
73110 X-ray exam of wrist 743,409
CMS
0.17
73120 X-ray exam of hand 286,082
CMS
0.16
73130 X-ray exam of hand 731,207
CMS
0.17
73140 X-ray exam of finger(s) 315,853
CMS
0.13
74000 X-ray exam of abdomen 1,847,189
CMS
0.18
74020 X-ray exam of abdomen 1,030,469
CMS
0.27
74022 X-ray exam series, abdomen 1,089,316
CMS
0.32
74150 CT abdomen w/o dye 1,155,454
CMS
1.19
74160 CT abdomen w/dye 2,018,764
CMS
1.27
75552 Heart MRI for morph w/o dye 1,113
ACC
1.6
75553 Heart MRI for morph w/dye 1,226
ACC
2.0
75554 Cardiac MRI/function 2,842
ACC
1.83
75555 Cardiac MRI/limited study 261
ACC
1.74
76075 DXA bone density, axial 2,428,543
CMS
0.3
76700 US exam, abdom, complete 1,367,513
CMS
0.81
76830 Transvaginal US, non-ob 303,687
CMS
0.69
77263 Radiation therapy planning 285,397
CMS
3.14
77280 Set radiation therapy field 231,871
CMS
0.7
77290 Set radiation therapy field 368,497
CMS
1.56
77300 Radiation therapy dose plan 1,266,334
CMS
0.62
77315 Teletx isodose plan complex 179,513
CMS
1.56
77331 Special radiation dosimetry 390,985
CMS
0.87
77334 Radiation treatment aid(s) 1,098,403
CMS
1.24
77470 Special radiation treatment 143,586
CMS
2.09
78306 Bone imaging, whole body 744,786
CMS
0.86
78315 Bone imaging, 3 phase 137,144
CMS
1.02
78465 Heart image (3d), multiple 2,751,144
CMS
1.46
78478 Heart wall motion add-on 2,531,282
CMS
0.62
78480 Heart function add-on 2,529,899
CMS
0.62